arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1108.2805stat.APcs.SIstat.ML
收藏

点名数据的分区分解

Partition Decomposition for Roll Call Data

Greg Leibon, Scott Pauls, Daniel N. Rockmore, Robert Savell

摘要:

本文将统计学习中的一些新工具应用于点名数据的分析。我们提出了一个新的数据驱动的模型,唱名投票,是几何性质。我们构建的模型,适应“分区解耦方法”,最初开发的时间序列的家庭分析的无监督学习技术,产生一个多尺度的几何描述的加权网络相关联的一组唱名表决。这种方法的核心是“动机”的定量概念,这是一个基于集群的学习基础元素,可以作为点名数据表示的构建块。动机使得能够对意识形态进行定量描述,而其依赖数据的性质使得有可能对意识形态因素的演变进行定量分析。这种方法通常适用于唱名数据,我们特别将其应用于美国众议院和参议院的历史唱名投票。该方法提供了一种用于估计底层动作空间的维度的机制。我们确定的主导因素形成了一个低(一个或两个)维的表示与次要因素添加高维特征。通过这种方式,我们的工作支持并扩展了Poole-Rosenthal和Heckman-Snyder关于动作空间维数的发现。我们对几个参议员进行了详细的分析,并使用统计学习中的AdaBoost技术来确定具有最强大歧视值的选票。当用作预测模型时,这种几何视图在原始准确性和聚合比例减少误差(APRE)方面都明显优于Poole-Rosenthal DW-NOMINATE模型和Heckman-Snyder 6因子模型等空间模型。

英文摘要:

In this paper we bring to bear some new tools from statistical learning on the analysis of roll call data. We present a new data-driven model for roll call voting that is geometric in nature. We construct the model by adapting the "Partition Decoupling Method," an unsupervised learning technique originally developed for the analysis of families of time series, to produce a multiscale geometric description of a weighted network associated to a set of roll call votes. Central to this approach is the quantitative notion of a "motivation," a cluster-based and learned basis element that serves as a building block in the representation of roll call data. Motivations enable the formulation of a quantitative description of ideology and their data-dependent nature makes possible a quantitative analysis of the evolution of ideological factors. This approach is generally applicable to roll call data and we apply it in particular to the historical roll call voting of the U.S. House and Senate. This methodology provides a mechanism for estimating the dimension of the underlying action space. We determine that the dominant factors form a low- (one- or two-) dimensional representation with secondary factors adding higher-dimensional features. In this way our work supports and extends the findings of both Poole-Rosenthal and Heckman-Snyder concerning the dimensionality of the action space. We give a detailed analysis of several individual Senates and use the AdaBoost technique from statistical learning to determine those votes with the most powerful discriminatory value. When used as a predictive model, this geometric view significantly outperforms spatial models such as the Poole-Rosenthal DW-NOMINATE model and the Heckman-Snyder 6-factor model, both in raw accuracy as well as Aggregate Proportional Reduced Error (APRE).

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑