arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1108.2006physics.ed-ph
收藏

非笛卡尔思维

Non-Cartesian Thinking

Mikhail Kagan

摘要:

正如我们通常在力学入门课程中所教的那样,选择一个具有方便轴的“好”参考系可能会使问题变得简单。此外,知道一些守恒量提供了一个非常强大的解决问题的工具。虽然前一个想法通常是在牛顿定律的背景下讨论的,但后者从引入能量守恒开始,甚至更晚。这项工作提出了一个优雅的例子,实现上述两个想法的运动学背景下,从而提供了一个“热身”的介绍,后来在动力学中使用的标准工具。(非正交)参考系和守恒量的选择都是相当不标准的,但同时对手头的问题来说是相当直观的。两个这样的问题进行了详细讨论,有两种替代方法。第一种方法甚至不需要微积分知识。在附录中,我也提出了蛮力解决方案,涉及一个耦合系统的微分方程。此外,最后还提供了几个练习题和另一个类似的学生“家庭作业”问题。

英文摘要:

As we typically teach in an introductory mechanics course, choosing a "good" reference frame with convenient axes may present a major simplification to a problem. Additionally, knowing some conserved quantities provides an extremely powerful problem-solving tool. While the former idea is typically discussed in the context of Newton's Laws, the latter starts with introducing conservation of energy even later. This work presents an elegant example of implementing both aforementioned ideas in the kinematical context, thus providing a "warm-up" introduction to the standard tools used later on in dynamics. Both the choice of the (non-orthogonal) reference frame and the conserved quantities are rather non-standard, yet at the same time quite intuitive to the problem at hand. Two such problems are discussed in detail with two alternative approaches. The first approach does not even require knowledge of calculus. In the appendix, I also present the brute-force solution involving a coupled system of differential equations. In addition, a few exercises and another similar problem for students' "homework" are provided at the end.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑