arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1106.3242cs.NIcs.GT
收藏

公共选择:网络中立的非监管替代方案

The Public Option: a Non-regulatory Alternative to Network Neutrality

Richard T. B. Ma, Vishal Misra

摘要:

网络中立性和监管在互联网上的作用近年来一直备受争议。在网络中立性的各种定义中,我们专注于禁止付费内容优先级的定义,并对该主题进行了分析处理。我们开发了一个互联网生态系统的三个主要参与者:消费者,互联网服务提供商和内容提供方的模型。我们的分析从消费者的角度来看待这个问题,我们将系统的理想状态描述为最大化消费者剩余的状态。通过分析垄断和竞争的不同情景,我们得出了不同的结论,管制的可取性。我们还介绍了一个公共选项ISP的概念,一个ISP,在网络中立的方式进行流量。我们的主要发现是:(一)在垄断的情况下,网络中立的法规有利于消费者;然而,引入公共选择ISP对消费者来说甚至更好,因为它使垄断ISP的利益与消费者剩余保持一致,并且(ii)在寡头垄断的情况下,公共选择ISP的存在再次优于网络中立法规,尽管竞争的价格歧视ISP的存在为消费者提供了最理想的情况。

英文摘要:

Network neutrality and the role of regulation on the Internet have been heavily debated in recent times. Amongst the various definitions of network neutrality, we focus on the one which prohibits paid prioritization of content and we present an analytical treatment of the topic. We develop a model of the Internet ecosystem in terms of three primary players: consumers, ISPs and content providers. Our analysis looks at this issue from the point of view of the consumer, and we describe the desired state of the system as one which maximizes consumer surplus. By analyzing different scenarios of monopoly and competition, we obtain different conclusions on the desirability of regulation. We also introduce the notion of a Public Option ISP, an ISP that carries traffic in a network neutral manner. Our major findings are (i) in a monopolistic scenario, network neutral regulations benefit consumers; however, the introduction of a Public Option ISP is even better for consumers, as it aligns the interests of the monopolistic ISP with the consumer surplus and (ii) in an oligopolistic situation, the presence of a Public Option ISP is again preferable to network neutral regulations, although the presence of competing price-discriminating ISPs provides the most desirable situation for the consumers.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑