如果专家们对同一个问题的答案趋于一致,那么他们的创造力是否比初学者低?根据适应性景观重新定义创造力
If Experts Converge on the Same Answer are they Less Creative than Beginners? Redefining Creativity in Terms of Adaptive Landscapes
摘要:
标准观点认为,创造力需要原创性和适当性,这导致了一个悖论,即集中在一个最佳解决方案上的专家并不比给出许多原创解决方案的初学者更具创造性。本文认为,创造力没有一个放之四海而皆准的定义;创造力必须相对于任务的限制和启示进行评估。与任务相关的适应性景观越平坦,创造力仅是原创性的功能的程度就越大。对于具有单峰适应性景观的任务,在独创性和适当性之间存在权衡。只有在具有崎岖的适应性景观的任务中,创造力才与原创性和适当性呈正相关。这表明,与艺术和科学的追求相关联的适应性景观同样崎岖,但对于艺术的追求,他们的拓扑结构反映了特殊的经验和情感(峰和谷不对齐)。
英文摘要:
The standard view that creativity entails both originality and appropriateness leads to the paradox that experts who converge on one optimal solution are rated as no more creative than beginners who give many original solutions. This paper asserts that there is no one-size-fits-all definition of creativity; creativity must be assessed relative to the constraints and affordances of the task. The flatter the adaptive landscape associated with the task, the greater the extent to which creativity is a function of originality only. For tasks with a single-peaked adaptive landscape, there is a tradeoff between originality and appropriateness. Only for tasks with rugged adaptive landscapes is creativity positively correlated with both originality and appropriateness. It is suggested that the adaptive landscapes associated with artistic and scientific pursuits are equally rugged, but for artistic pursuits their topologies reflect idiosyncratic experiences and emotions (the peaks and valleys are not aligned).
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。