对“相互作用粒子过阻尼运动的热统计学”[ arXiv:1104.0697]一文评论的答复Levin和R.帕克泰
Reply to the comment on: "Thermostatistics of Overdamped Motion of Interacting Particles" [arXiv:1104.0697] by Y. Levin and R. Pakter
摘要:
我们发现Levin和Pakter对我们的工作[arXiv:1008.1421]的评论[arXiv:1104.0697]在概念上是没有根据的,包含误导性的解释,并且是基于可疑的适用性的结果。我们最初提供的论据表明,令人费解的是,这些作者只是选择断然拒绝我们精心设计和坚实的概念方法,结果和分析,而没有采用统计物理学的任何基本概念或工具。然后,我们证明,莱文和帕克特的结果并没有提出任何证据反对,而是证实了我们的结论。事实上,他们的评论中显示的结果对应于比我们研究中使用的典型值强1000倍的限制势,因此解释了他们的结果与我们的结果之间的差异。此外,在涉及更高涡流密度的这种状态下,涡核可能彼此如此接近,以至于不能再被视为点状缺陷。因此,应该采用金兹伯格-朗道方程,这意味着莱文和帕克特的结果所隐含的物理条件应该在相互作用的超导涡旋物理学的背景下谨慎考虑。
英文摘要:
We show that the comment [arXiv:1104.0697] by Levin and Pakter on our work [arXiv:1008.1421] is conceptually unfounded, contains misleading interpretations, and is based on results of questionable applicability. We initially provide arguments to evince that, inexplicably, these authors simply choose to categorically dismiss our elaborated and solid conceptual approach, results and analysis, without employing any fundamental concepts or tools from Statistical Physics. We then demonstrate that the results of Levin and Pakter do not present any evidence against, but rather corroborates, our conclusions. In fact, the results shown in their comment correspond to a confining potential that is 1000 times stronger than the typical valued utilized in our study, therefore explaining the discrepancy between their results and ours. Furthermore, in this regime where higher vortex densities are involved, vortex cores might get so close to each other that can no longer be treated as point-like defects. As a consequence, Ginzburg-Landau equations should be employed instead, meaning that the physical conditions implied by the results of Levin and Pakter should be considered with caution in the context of the Physics of interacting superconducting vortexes.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。