评“以约1.5的精度计算所有基本基本粒子的质量”1%”[Journal of Modern Physics，2010，1，300-302]
Comment on "Calculation of the Masses of All Fundamental Elementary Particles with an Accuracy of Approx. 1%" [Journal of Modern Physics, 2010, 1, 300-302]
摘要：
在最近的一篇论文中，K。O. Greulich提出了一个经验的、单参数的规则，该规则被声称可以预测所有基本基本粒子的质量。这种说法似乎是正确的，因为一些实验和计算的基本质量的比较得到了支持。作者承认，在孤立的单个粒子的情况下，一个好的结果可以仅仅通过偶然来实现。他还指出，在1%的精度内，所有基本质量的整个系综偶然拟合的概率接近于零。然而，可以观察到，与他的模型的正确性相关的11个粒子中只有8个在1%的准确度内满足公式，并且这个结果可以通过偶然简单地实现。
英文摘要：
In a recent paper, K. O. Greulich propose an empirical, one-parameter rule which is claimed to predict the masses of all fundamental elementary particles. This statement seems to be true as sustained by the comparison of some experimental and calculated elementary masses. The author admits that in the case of an isolated single particle a good result could be achieved simply by chance. He also states that the probability to fit by chance the whole ensemble of all elementary masses within 1% accuracy is close to zero. However, one may observe that only 8 of the 11 particles which are relevant for the correctness of his model satisfy the formula within 1% accuracy and this result could have been achieved simple by chance.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来，可能存在错误，请以论文正文为准。
