概率中的奖品洞察力,以及一个循环错误的山羊:杰森罗森豪斯的蒙蒂霍尔问题
Prize insights in probability, and one goat of a recycled error: Jason Rosenhouse's The Monty Hall Problem
摘要:
蒙蒂霍尔问题是一个电视游戏场景,你,参赛者,被呈现在三扇门后面,一辆车藏在一扇门后面,山羊藏在另外两扇门后面。在你选择一扇门后,主持人(蒙蒂·霍尔)打开第二扇门,露出一只山羊。然后,你被邀请留在你原来选择的门,或切换到剩下的未打开的门,并声称无论你发现它后面.假设你的目标是赢得汽车,你的最佳策略是留下或切换,还是不重要?杰森·罗森豪斯对这个游戏进行了权威性的分析,以及几个有趣的变化,并讨论了它的一些心理和哲学含义。这篇扩展的评论从贝叶斯的角度详细地研究了书中的几个主题,并指出了一个明显的无意错误。
英文摘要:
The Monty Hall problem is the TV game scenario where you, the contestant, are presented with three doors, with a car hidden behind one and goats hidden behind the other two. After you select a door, the host (Monty Hall) opens a second door to reveal a goat. You are then invited to stay with your original choice of door, or to switch to the remaining unopened door, and claim whatever you find behind it. Assuming your objective is to win the car, is your best strategy to stay or switch, or does it not matter? Jason Rosenhouse has provided the definitive analysis of this game, along with several intriguing variations, and discusses some of its psychological and philosophical implications. This extended review examines several themes from the book in some detail from a Bayesian perspective, and points out one apparently inadvertent error.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。