公共和私人保护政策之间的权衡模型
Modelling trade offs between public and private conservation policies
摘要:
为了减少全球生物多样性的损失,迫切需要确定保护资源的最有效分配。近年来,许多国家政府越来越倾向于以私人土地保护的激励计划来补充保护区的公有制和管理。与此同时,促进保护私人土地的政策很少从生态后果的角度进行评估。这就提出了一些重要的问题,例如私人土地保护在多大程度上可以改善保护成果,以及如何将其与更传统的公共土地保护相结合。我们解决这些问题,使用一个总体框架,模拟环境政策和案例研究,研究濒危的本土草原保护西部的澳大利亚墨尔本。具体来说,我们研究了三项政策,涉及:一)花费所有的资源创建公共保护区;二)花费所有的资源在一个持续的激励计划,私人土地所有者支付管理植被的财产与5年的合同;和iii)这两种方法之间的分裂资源。每个策略的性能量化与植被条件变化模型,预测未来的草地质量的变化。在所测试的政策中,没有一项政策总是最好的,政策绩效取决于政策制定者的目标。这项工作展示了一个一般的方法来评估环境政策,并强调了实用的模型,结合生态和社会经济过程。
英文摘要:
To reduce global biodiversity loss, there is an urgent need to determine the most efficient allocation of conservation resources. Recently, there has been a growing trend for many governments to supplement public ownership and management of reserves with incentive programs for conservation on private land. At the same time, policies to promote conservation on private land are rarely evaluated in terms of their ecological consequences. This raises important questions, such as the extent to which private land conservation can improve conservation outcomes, and how it should be mixed with more traditional public land conservation. We address these questions, using a general framework for modelling environmental policies and a case study examining the conservation of endangered native grasslands to the west of Melbourne, Australia. Specifically, we examine three policies that involve: i) spending all resources on creating public conservation areas; ii) spending all resources on an ongoing incentive program where private landholders are paid to manage vegetation on their property with 5-year contracts; and iii) splitting resources between these two approaches. The performance of each strategy is quantified with a vegetation condition change model that predicts future changes in grassland quality. Of the policies tested, no one policy was always best and policy performance depended on the objectives of those enacting the policy. This work demonstrates a general method for evaluating environmental policies and highlights the utility of a model which combines ecological and socioeconomic processes.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。