好,伟大,还是幸运?基于重尾先验的业绩持续优异企业筛选
Good, great, or lucky? Screening for firms with sustained superior performance using heavy-tailed priors
摘要:
本文考察了93个国家的53,038家上市公司在过去45年中的ROA(资产回报率)历史模式。我们的目标是筛选那些ROA轨迹表明他们随着时间的推移系统性地优于同行群体的公司。这样一个项目至少面临三个统计困难:相关协变量的调整,大量的多重性和纵向依赖性。我们的结论是,一旦考虑到这些困难,明显优越的性能似乎是相当罕见的。我们比较我们的研究结果与其他最近的管理研究相同的主题,并与流行的文学对企业的成功。我们的方法的贡献是提出了一个新的类的先验用于大规模的同时测试。这些先验是基于超几何的倒β族,并有两个主要的吸引力的特点:重尾和计算的易处理性。该族是正态/逆β先验的四参数推广,并且是分层正态模型中收缩系数的自然共轭先验。我们的研究结果强调了这些重尾先验在大型多重测试问题中的有用性,因为它们在边缘似然$m(y)$中具有温和的尾衰减率--这是一种长期被认为在测试中很重要的属性。
英文摘要:
This paper examines historical patterns of ROA (return on assets) for a cohort of 53,038 publicly traded firms across 93 countries, measured over the past 45 years. Our goal is to screen for firms whose ROA trajectories suggest that they have systematically outperformed their peer groups over time. Such a project faces at least three statistical difficulties: adjustment for relevant covariates, massive multiplicity, and longitudinal dependence. We conclude that, once these difficulties are taken into account, demonstrably superior performance appears to be quite rare. We compare our findings with other recent management studies on the same subject, and with the popular literature on corporate success. Our methodological contribution is to propose a new class of priors for use in large-scale simultaneous testing. These priors are based on the hypergeometric inverted-beta family, and have two main attractive features: heavy tails and computational tractability. The family is a four-parameter generalization of the normal/inverted-beta prior, and is the natural conjugate prior for shrinkage coefficients in a hierarchical normal model. Our results emphasize the usefulness of these heavy-tailed priors in large multiple-testing problems, as they have a mild rate of tail decay in the marginal likelihood $m(y)$---a property long recognized to be important in testing.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。