评“奇异和弱色散极限中的光学前兆”
Comment on "Optical precursors in the singular and weak dispersion limits"
摘要:
我们指出Oughstun等人最近关于索末菲和布里渊前体的论文中的不一致之处[J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 27,1664-1670(2010)]。他们的研究基本上是数值的,对于他们在模拟中使用的参数,所考虑的两个极限之间的差异并不像他们所说的那样明确。在奇异极限中获得的布里渊前体的急剧上升,并作为该极限的一个显着特征进行分析,仅仅是由于一个不合适的时间尺度。事实上,前兆的上升是渐进的,并且由艾里函数完美地描述。在弱色散极限,等价关系,建立在第3节的文件,作为一个直接的结果出现在延迟时间的图片。最后但并非最不重要的是,我们表明,与作者声称的相反,前体是灾难性的入射光场的上升时间的影响,即使后者是相当快的介质弛豫时间。
英文摘要:
We point out inconsistencies in the recent paper by Oughstun et al. on Sommerfeld and Brillouin precursors [J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 27, 1664-1670 (2010)]. Their study is essentially numerical and, for the parameters used in their simulations, the difference between the two limits considered is not as clear-cut as they state. The steep rise of the Brillouin precursor obtained in the singular limit and analyzed as a distinguishing feature of this limit simply results from an unsuitable time scale. In fact, the rise of the precursor is progressive and is perfectly described by a Airy function. In the weak dispersion limit, the equivalence relation, established at great length in Section 3 of the paper, appears as an immediate result in the retarded-time picture. Last but not least, we show that, contrary to the authors claim, the precursors are catastrophically affected by the rise-time of the incident optical field, even when the latter is considerably faster than the medium relaxation time.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。