作者在编写科学手稿时没有遵循文献调查的良好做法
Good practices for a literature survey are not followed by authors while preparing scientific manuscripts
摘要:
作者在科学期刊上的被引次数已经成为通过影响因子来评估研究人员和期刊本身的一个主要参数。因此,一个公平的评估要求在给定的手稿中选择参考文献的标准应该对作者或引用的期刊没有偏见。在本文中,我们主张作者在研究特定研究的文献时应遵循两个强制性原则来选择论文(稍后反映在参考文献列表中):i)考虑内容与所研究主题的相似性,以免非常相关的工作被复制或忽略; ii)在引文网络中进行系统搜索,包括开创性或非常相关的论文。我们使用复杂网络的形式主义从arXiv存储库的论文的两个数据集,以表明这两个标准都没有在实践中得到满足。
英文摘要:
The number of citations received by authors in scientific journals has become a major parameter to assess individual researchers and the journals themselves through the impact factor. A fair assessment therefore requires that the criteria for selecting references in a given manuscript should be unbiased with respect to the authors or the journals cited. In this paper, we advocate that authors should follow two mandatory principles to select papers (later reflected in the list of references) while studying the literature for a given research: i) consider similarity of content with the topics investigated, lest very related work should be reproduced or ignored; ii) perform a systematic search over the network of citations including seminal or very related papers. We use formalisms of complex networks for two datasets of papers from the arXiv repository to show that neither of these two criteria is fulfilled in practice.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。