arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1003.1018physics.data-ancs.DBstat.AP
收藏

跨领域和机构科学产出测量中的齐普夫定律和对数正态分布:斯洛文尼亚40年研究为例

Zipf's law and log-normal distributions in measures of scientific output across fields and institutions: 40 years of Slovenia's research as an example

Matjaz Perc

摘要:

斯洛文尼亚的当前研究信息系统(SICRIS)目前拥有86,443种出版物,引用数据来自1970年至今从事大量社会和自然科学研究的8,359名研究人员。使用这些数据,我们表明,来自个别出版物的引用分布具有Zipfian属性,因为它们可以拟合的幂律$P(x) \sim x^{-α}$,与$α$之间的2.4和3.1取决于机构和研究领域。另一方面,量化研究人员而不是单个出版物的成功的指数的分布不能与幂律相关联。我们发现,对于Egghe的g-指数和Hirsch的h-指数的对数正态形式$P(x) \sim \exp[-a\ln x -b(\ln x)^2]$适用最好的,与$a$和$b$适度依赖于底层的一组研究人员。在特殊情况下,特别是对于具有强烈等级结构的机构和具有高自引率的研究领域,也可以观察到指数分布。这两个指数产生具有相同统计特性的分布,这是其一致性和逻辑连通性的强有力指标。与此同时,对个别研究人员的引文历史评估的差异加强了他们对正确评估科学产出的质量和影响的重要性。

英文摘要:

Slovenia's Current Research Information System (SICRIS) currently hosts 86,443 publications with citation data from 8,359 researchers working on the whole plethora of social and natural sciences from 1970 till present. Using these data, we show that the citation distributions derived from individual publications have Zipfian properties in that they can be fitted by a power law $P(x) \sim x^{-α}$, with $α$ between 2.4 and 3.1 depending on the institution and field of research. Distributions of indexes that quantify the success of researchers rather than individual publications, on the other hand, cannot be associated with a power law. We find that for Egghe's g-index and Hirsch's h-index the log-normal form $P(x) \sim \exp[-a\ln x -b(\ln x)^2]$ applies best, with $a$ and $b$ depending moderately on the underlying set of researchers. In special cases, particularly for institutions with a strongly hierarchical constitution and research fields with high self-citation rates, exponential distributions can be observed as well. Both indexes yield distributions with equivalent statistical properties, which is a strong indicator for their consistency and logical connectedness. At the same time, differences in the assessment of citation histories of individual researchers strengthen their importance for properly evaluating the quality and impact of scientific output.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑