arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1001.3745cs.IRcs.AIcs.DBphysics.soc-ph
收藏

离散与连续值评级对声誉和排名系统的影响

The effect of discrete vs. continuous-valued ratings on reputation and ranking systems

Université de Fribourg(弗里堡大学);Institut Jean Nicod (CNRS)(让·尼科研究所(法国国家科学研究中心));École Normale Supérieure(巴黎高等师范学院);CREATE-NET Research Consortium(CREATE-NET研究联盟)

Matus Medo, Joseph Rushton Wakeling

摘要:

当用户对对象进行评级时,考虑到能力或声誉的复杂算法可能会产生比简单的算术平均值更公平或更准确的评级聚合。最近,一些作者提出了不同的共同确定算法,其中用户和对象的声誉的估计一起迭代细化,允许准确的措施,直接从评级数据。然而,模拟证明这些方法的有效性假设了一个连续的评级值,符合典型的物理建模实践,而在大多数实际评级系统中,只有有限范围的离散值(如5星级系统)。我们进行了比较测试的几个共同决定的算法与不同规模的离散评级,并表明,这种看似微小的修改,实际上有一个显着的影响算法的性能。奇怪的是,在评级分辨率较低的情况下,用户评级中增加的噪声甚至可以提高系统的整体性能。

英文摘要:

When users rate objects, a sophisticated algorithm that takes into account ability or reputation may produce a fairer or more accurate aggregation of ratings than the straightforward arithmetic average. Recently a number of authors have proposed different co-determination algorithms where estimates of user and object reputation are refined iteratively together, permitting accurate measures of both to be derived directly from the rating data. However, simulations demonstrating these methods' efficacy assumed a continuum of rating values, consistent with typical physical modelling practice, whereas in most actual rating systems only a limited range of discrete values (such as a 5-star system) is employed. We perform a comparative test of several co-determination algorithms with different scales of discrete ratings and show that this seemingly minor modification in fact has a significant impact on algorithms' performance. Paradoxically, where rating resolution is low, increased noise in users' ratings may even improve the overall performance of the system.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑