arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 0911.5400physics.hist-phgr-qchep-th
收藏

经验等价、人工规范自由和广义Kretschmann反对

Empirical Equivalence, Artificial Gauge Freedom and a Generalized Kretschmann Objection

J. Brian Pitts

摘要:

爱因斯坦认为广义协变性是他的广义相对论(GTR)的新颖特征,但克雷奇曼认为这只是任何理论都可能具有的形式特征。GTR“已经参数化”的主张表明,将实质性的广义协方差分析为正式的广义协方差,而不将首选坐标隐藏为标量“时钟场”,就像爱因斯坦将广义协方差解释为缺乏首选坐标一样。物理学家经常用额外的场来人为地建立规范对称性,如从普罗卡电磁学到施蒂克尔伯格电磁学的转变。一些后实证主义哲学家,由于现实主义的同情,致力于判断施图克尔伯格的电磁学不同于和低于普罗卡的。相比之下,物理学家识别它们,差异是规范依赖的,因此是不真实的。在具有破缺的规范对称性(第二类约束)的理论中,使用修改的Batalin-Fradkin-Typhon(BFT)程序来安装规范自由度通常是有用的。大规模的GTR,参数化和拉格朗日BFT类似的程序似乎是一致的,模仿GTR的一般协方差除了告诉时钟字段。安装人工规范自由度的一般程序包含参数化和BFT,同时比BFT更拉格朗日友好,保持任何主要约束不变,并使用非BFT边界条件。人工规范自由许可证的广义Kretschmann反对。然而,人工规范自由的范式案例的特征可能有助于证明实质性规范对称性和仅仅形式上的规范对称性之间的原则性区别。

英文摘要:

Einstein considered general covariance to characterize the novelty of his General Theory of Relativity (GTR), but Kretschmann thought it merely a formal feature that any theory could have. The claim that GTR is "already parametrized" suggests analyzing substantive general covariance as formal general covariance achieved without hiding preferred coordinates as scalar "clock fields," much as Einstein construed general covariance as the lack of preferred coordinates. Physicists often install gauge symmetries artificially with additional fields, as in the transition from Proca's to Stueckelberg's electromagnetism. Some post-positivist philosophers, due to realist sympathies, are committed to judging Stueckelberg's electromagnetism distinct from and inferior to Proca's. By contrast, physicists identify them, the differences being gauge-dependent and hence unreal. It is often useful to install gauge freedom in theories with broken gauge symmetries (second-class constraints) using a modified Batalin-Fradkin-Tyutin (BFT) procedure. Massive GTR, for which parametrization and a Lagrangian BFT-like procedure appear to coincide, mimics GTR's general covariance apart from telltale clock fields. A generalized procedure for installing artificial gauge freedom subsumes parametrization and BFT, while being more Lagrangian-friendly than BFT, leaving any primary constraints unchanged and using a non-BFT boundary condition. Artificial gauge freedom licenses a generalized Kretschmann objection. However, features of paradigm cases of artificial gauge freedom might help to demonstrate a principled distinction between substantive and merely formal gauge symmetry.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑