arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 0909.1057nucl-ex
收藏

对“发现原子序数112的元素”的回应。Heinz W. Barber Gaggeler,Paul J. Karol,Hiromichi Nakahara,Emanuele Vardaci and Erich Vogt(PAC-REP-08-03-05)

Response to "Discovery of the element with atomic number 112" by Robert C. Barber, Heinz W. Gaggeler, Paul J. Karol, Hiromichi Nakahara, Emanuele Vardaci and Erich Vogt (PAC-REP-08-03-05)

Amnon Marinov, Dietmar Kolb, Jesse L. Weil

摘要:

基于两个α粒子链,联合工作组(JWP)报告将发现112号元素的优先级分配给了达姆施塔特GSI在1996年和2002年所做的工作。通过这样做,它忽略了提交给联合工作方案的关于早在1971年由Marinov等人发现这种元素的数据。在这些测量中,从两个Hg源中观察到大约100个裂变碎片,这两个Hg源与两个W靶分开,用24 GeV质子辐照。此外,裂变物质的质量被测量和解释为由于原子和四个不同的分子的元素112与原子质量数272-273。联合工作方案忽略了这些数据,忽视了这样一个事实,即质量测量被Transfermium工作组(TWG)的报告视为“极好的标准”,“化学方法可以产生极好的分配标准”。下文表明,联合工作方案为证明其决定的合理性而提出的所有论点都是可以反驳的。特别是,他们拒绝接受长寿命同质异能态存在的可能性作为对数据的一致解释是不合理的,因为,在其他观察中,最近已经发现了天然存在的中子缺乏211,213,217,218 Th同位素中存在这种状态的证据,以及超重元素区域,在原子质量数A = 261和A = 265(最有可能是261 Rg和265 Rg)时,在A = 292时,Z =~122(类钍),半衰期t1/2 >= 10^8 y。

英文摘要:

Based on two alpha-particle chains the Joint Working Party (JWP) Report assigns the priority for discovering element 112 to work done in 1996 and 2002 at GSI, Darmstadt. By doing this it ignores the data presented to the JWP about the discovery of this element already back in 1971 by Marinov et al. In those measurements about one hundred fission fragments were observed from two Hg sources separated from two W targets irradiated with 24 GeV protons. Furthermore, the masses of the fissioning species were measured and interpreted as being due to the atom and four different molecules of element 112 with atomic mass number 272-273. By ignoring these data the JWP disregards the facts that mass measurement is considered by the Transfermium Working Group (TWG) report as an "excellent criterion" and that "chemical methods can yield excellent assignment criteria". It is shown below that all the arguments given by the JWP attempting to justify their decision are refutable. In particular, their refusal to accept the possibility of the existence of long-lived isomeric states as a consistent interpretation of the data is unjustified, since, among other observations, evidence has been found recently for the existence of such states in naturally-occurring neutron deficient 211,213,217,218Th isotopes, and in the superheavy element region, at atomic mass numbers A = 261 and A = 265 (most probably 261Rg and 265Rg), and at A = 292, Z =~122 (eka-Th), with half-lives t1/2 >= 10^8 y.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑