论物理学的教与学:批判与系统的方法
On the teaching and learning of physics: A Criticism and a Systemic Approach
摘要:
《物理教育研究》(PER)发表的大量研究表明,一方面,人们对设计和开发高绩效的物理教学策略越来越感兴趣,另一方面,人们试图了解大脑处理科学信息的合理方式,以便更有效地教授科学思维技能。由于物理学是一门数学推理和概念推理不可分离的学科,物理教师面临着如何找到最有效的物理教学方法的问题(即应该花多少时间在直观的概念推理上,花多少时间在发展定量推理上,以及如何以统一的方式教授两者)。尽管PER社区做出了重要的努力,但发表的结果对物理教师来说是压倒性的和令人困惑的,因为这些文章中出现的结论在某些情况下是有争议的,并且在指出克服上述问题的特定策略方面远远不是决定性的。因此,根据对已发表的PER工作的分析,我们将认为,在物理教学中要克服的主要困难之一可能与缺乏一个一致和连贯的教学方法框架有关,该框架将概念和数学推理这两个方面结合起来,以系统的思维方式。我们将提出一套可行的步骤,可用于解决上述困难。
英文摘要:
The amount of published research in Physics Education Research (PER) shows, on one hand, an increasing interest in the design and development of high performance physics teaching strategies, and, on the other hand, it tries to understand plausible ways on which the brain processes scientific information so that scientific thinking skills could be taught more effectively. As physics is a subject in which mathematical and conceptual reasoning can not be separated, instructors of physics face the problem of finding suitable advise on the most effective methods of teaching physics (i.e. how much time should be spent on intuitive conceptual reasoning and how much time in developing quantitative reasoning, and how to teach both in a unitary way). In spite the important efforts made by the PER community, the published results are overwhelming and confusing for the physics instructors in the sense that the conclusions that have arisen in those articles are in some instances controversial and far from being conclusive in pointing out a particular strategy to overcome the afore mentioned problem. Accordingly, based on the analysis of published PER work, we'll be arguing that one of the major difficulties to overcome in the teaching of physics could be associated to the lack of a consistent and coherent methodological framework for teaching which integrates both aspects, conceptual and mathematical reasoning, in a systemic way of thinking. We will be presenting a set of plausible steps that could be applied to tackle the aforementioned difficulty.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。