arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 0808.3432quant-ph
收藏

评“两种方法计算共振荧光光谱的差异”

Comment on "Discrepancies in the resonance-fluorescence spectrum calculated with two methods"

Z. Ficek

摘要:

在文献中有两种替代方法用于计算原子系统散射的光谱的非相干部分。第一种方法是计算系统散射光的光谱,减去相干部分得到非相干部分。第二种方法是引入涨落算符,通过对涨落算符的两个时间关联函数进行傅里叶变换,得到谱的非相干部分。这两种方法多年来一直被认为是计算光谱非相干部分的两种完全等效的方法。Qing Xu等人[Phys.Rev.A78,013407(2008)]在最近的一篇论文中指出,用这两种方法计算的三能级λ型系统的定态谱的非相干部分之间存在差异。预测的差异可能是严重的,在拉比频率和原子衰变率的宽范围内,用方差法计算的光谱可能具有负值。这显然是非物理的结果,因为荧光光谱是一个明确定义的量。它代表了原子系统非相干散射光的频率分布。因此,计算的频谱应该是积极的所有频率的拉比频率和阻尼率的值无关。在这篇评论中,我们表明这两种方法之间没有差异。这两种替代方法的等价性导致相同的非相干谱,其对于所有频率都是正的,与所涉及的参数值无关。简单的数值计算支持的分析。

英文摘要:

There are two alternative methods used in literature to calculate the incoherent part of the spectrum of light scattered by an atomic system. In the first, one calculates the spectrum of the total light scattered by the system and obtains the incoherent part by subtracting the coherent part. In the second method, one introduces the fluctuation operators and obtains the incoherent part of the spectrum by taking the Fourier transform of the two time correlation function of the fluctuation operators. These two methods have been recognized for years as two completely equivalent for evaluating the incoherent part of the spectrum. In a recent paper Qing Xu et al. [Phys. Rev. A 78, 013407 (2008)] have shown that there are discrepancies between the incoherent parts of the stationary spectrum of a three-level Lambda-type system calculated with these two methods. The predicted discrepancies can be severe that over a wide rage of the Rabi frequencies and atomic decay rates, the spectrum calculated with the variance method can have negative values. This is obviously unphysical result since the fluorescence spectrum is a positively defined quantity. It represents the frequency distribution of light incoherently scattered by the atomic system. Therefore, the calculated spectrum should be positive for all frequencies independent of values of the Rabi frequencies and the damping rates. In this comment, we show that there are no discrepancies between these two methods. The equivalence of these two alternative methods leads to the same incoherent spectra that are positive for all frequencies independent of values of the parameters involved. The analytical analysis is supported by simple numerical calculations.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑