给编辑的信。NAA和JFK:修正主义能把我们带回家吗?
Letter to the editor. NAA and JFK: Can revisionism take us home?
摘要:
在人类学习过程中,我们偶尔会遇到异常现象。尽管我们可能会尝试,但这是一种违背适当分类的异常。Spiegelman等人最近的论文-- JFK暗杀子弹批次的化学和法医分析:第二个射手可能吗?就是这样一种偏差。它充满了误解和事实错误。声称对文森特·吉恩博士在调查约翰·F·肯尼迪总统遇刺案中所做的中子活化分析工作提出质疑。肯尼迪,它失败得很惨。这篇论文提出了两个中心结论,一个显然是错误的,另一个是似是而非的。作者认为;``如果暗杀碎片来自三枚或更多单独的子弹,那么很可能是第二个刺客,因为额外的子弹不会归因于主要嫌疑人奥斯瓦尔德先生。“这种基于三颗或三颗以上子弹的前提下关于第二个刺客的可能性的说法显然是错误的。现有证据表明,奥斯瓦尔德开了三枪,其中一枪据信没有击中。然而,如果这三枪都击中了(尽管绝对没有其他支持这一观点的法医证据),那么这三枪就不可能表明有第二个刺客。作者之所以得出错误的结论,是因为他们要么被误导了(我个人认为是这样),要么就是他们根本不熟悉证据。
英文摘要:
Occasionally during the course of the human learning experience we are faced with an anomaly. An aberration of sorts, which try as we might, defies appropriate classification. The recent paper by Spiegelman et al.--Chemical and forensic analysis of JFK assassination bullet lots: Is a second shooter possible?--is one such aberration. It is riddled with both misconceptions and errors of fact. Purporting to cast doubt on the NAA (neutron activation analysis) work conducted by Dr. Vincent Guinn in the investigation of the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, it fails miserably. The paper offers two central conclusions, one which is demonstrably false, and the other which is specious. The authors opine; ``If the assassination fragments are derived from three or more separate bullets, then a second assassin is likely, as the additional bullet would not be attributable to the main suspect, Mr. Oswald.'' This statement relating to the likelihood of a second assassin based on the premise of three or more separate bullets is demonstrably false. The available evidence indicates that Oswald fired three shots, one of which is believed to have missed. However, on the off chance that all three shots hit (even though there is absolutely no other supporting forensic evidence for such a notion) those three shots alone in no way would indicate then that ``a second assassin is likely.'' The authors' erroneous conclusion was achieved because they have either been misled (which I personally believe is the case) or they simply aren't familiar with the evidence.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。