arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 0707.0878math.OCcs.SYeess.SYmath.STstat.TH
收藏

鲁棒控制中的风险分析——为概率鲁棒控制辩护

Risk Analysis in Robust Control -- Making the Case for Probabilistic Robust Control

Louisiana State University(路易斯安那州立大学)

Xinjia Chen, Jorge Aravena, Kemin Zhou

AI总结:

本文批判了鲁棒控制设计中的“最坏情况”方法,通过案例分析表明概率方法在风险控制上可能更优,并量化了最坏情况设计的高风险。

摘要:

本文对作为鲁棒控制设计基石的“最坏情况”方法提出了批判性观点。我们认为,盲目接受最坏情况场景可能导致的设计实际上比基于内置风险因子的概率技术更危险。真正的问题在于建模。如果承认不确定性没有完美的数学模型,那么概率方法可以导致更可靠的控制,即使它不能保证在所有可能情况下的稳定性。我们的论述基于案例分析。我们首先确定最坏情况不一定是“包罗万象的”。事实上,我们表明,对于某些不确定控制问题,要获得传统的鲁棒控制解,必须做出排除某些可行情况的假设。一旦我们确立了这一点,我们论证最坏情况设计中未考虑情况的风险并不罕见地大于概率方法中接受的风险。通过一个例子,我们量化了风险,并表明最坏情况可能显著更具风险。最后,我们将我们的分析与关于计算复杂性和概率鲁棒性的现有结果相结合,论证确定性最坏情况分析不一定更好。

英文摘要:

This paper offers a critical view of the "worst-case" approach that is the cornerstone of robust control design. It is our contention that a blind acceptance of worst-case scenarios may lead to designs that are actually more dangerous than designs based on probabilistic techniques with a built-in risk factor. The real issue is one of modeling. If one accepts that no mathematical model of uncertainties is perfect then a probabilistic approach can lead to more reliable control even if it cannot guarantee stability for all possible cases. Our presentation is based on case analysis. We first establish that worst-case is not necessarily "all-encompassing." In fact, we show that for some uncertain control problems to have a conventional robust control solution it is necessary to make assumptions that leave out some feasible cases. Once we establish that point, we argue that it is not uncommon for the risk of unaccounted cases in worst-case design to be greater than that of the accepted risk in a probabilistic approach. With an example, we quantify the risks and show that worst-case can be significantly more risky. Finally, we join our analysis with existing results on computational complexity and probabilistic robustness to argue that the deterministic worst-case analysis is not necessarily the better tool.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑