$Λ$ CDM宇宙学:有多少可信的证据被压制了,使用所有的证据,这个模型真的领先于它的竞争对手吗?
$Λ$CDM cosmology: how much suppression of credible evidence, and does the model really lead its competitors, using all evidence?
摘要:
天文学永远不可能成为一门核心物理学科,因为宇宙没有提供控制实验,也就是说,没有独立的检查,它必然是高度模糊和退化的。例如,超光速运动可以用狭义相对论来解释。关于前者的数据本身绝不能用来确定后者。这就是为什么传统上天体物理学家一直满足于(并自豪于)他们使用已知的物理定律和实验室建立的过程来解释天体现象的能力。宇宙学甚至不是天体物理学:这一领域的所有主要假设都没有在实验室中得到证实(或无法证实),研究人员非常乐意发明未知来解释未知。那么,在五十年来寻找暗物质的失败尝试之后,暗物质领域{ \it和现在}暗能量怎么会成为天文学基金中如此崇高的优先事项,而损害了天文学的所有其他分支?我在这篇文章中证明,虽然其中一些是基于真理,但至少有同样多的$Λ$ CDM宇宙学受到了大量宣传的支持,这些宣传压制了反证,压制了竞争模型。Spergel等人(2007)最近的WMAP 3论文将被用作选择性引用的案例。我还表明,当所有的证据都考虑在内,两个竞争的模型,消除暗能量和/或暗物质不落后于$Λ$ CDM很多。鉴于上述所有情况,我相信天文学不再走向健康的未来,除非资助机构重新考虑他们的总体规划,放弃如此高度重视在黑暗中摸索。
英文摘要:
Astronomy can never be a hard core physics discipline, because the Universe offers no control experiment, i.e. with no independent checks it is bound to be highly ambiguous and degenerate. Thus e.g. while superluminal motion can be explained by Special Relativity. data on the former can never on their own be used to establish the latter. This is why traditionally astrophysicists have been content with (and proud of) their ability to use known physical laws and processes established in the laboratory to explain celestial phenomena. Cosmology is not even astrophysics: all the principal assumptions in this field are unverified (or unverifiable) in the laboratory, and researchers are quite comfortable with inventing unknowns to explain the unknown. How then could, after fifty years of failed attempt in finding dark matter, the fields of dark matter {\it and now} dark energy have become such lofty priorities in astronomy funding, to the detriment of all other branches of astronomy? I demonstrate in this article that while some of is based upon truth, at least just as much of $Λ$CDM cosmology has been propped by a paralyzing amount of propaganda which suppress counter evidence and subdue competing models. The recent WMAP3 paper of Spergel et al (2007) will be used as case in point on selective citation. I also show that when all evidence are taken into account, two of the competing models that abolish dark energy and/or dark matter do not trail behind $Λ$CDM by much. Given all of the above, I believe astronomy is no longer heading towards a healthy future, unless funding agencies re-think their master plans by backing away from such high a emphasis on groping in the dark.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。