The Challenge of Cell Segmentation in Spatially Resolved Transcriptomics
空间分辨转录组学中细胞分割的挑战
Naveed Ishaque, Peter Kharchenko, Daria Lazic, Jieran Sun, Jean Yee Hwa Yang, Martin Emons, Florian Heyl, Wolfgang Huber, Daniel Jones, Louis B. Kuemmerle, Alex R. Lederer, Malte D. Luecken, Vinicius Maracaja-Coutinho, Matthias Meyer-Bender, Andrew Moorman, Evan W. Newell, Quan Nguyen, Shyam Prabhakar, John Randell, Daria Romanovskaia, Oliver Stegle, Gary D. Bader, Raphael Gottardo
AI总结 本文指出空间分辨转录组学中细胞分割是核心未解决问题,分析了稀疏信号、转录本位移等挑战,并呼吁建立共享评估框架和基准数据集。
详情
空间分辨转录组学(SRT)通过测量细胞在其空间背景下的基因表达,正在改变我们研究组织的方式。然而,该领域在其最基本的分析步骤之一——如何准确分割细胞并将空间定位的转录本分配给它们——缺乏稳健的方法学指导。主要技术挑战包括稀疏的分子信号、转录本位移、复杂的细胞形态以及将三维组织结构投影到二维成像平面上。这些挑战使得分割成为不确定性的主要来源,错误可能传播到下游分析,最终导致误导性的生物学解释。在此,我们认为分割应被视为空间组学中一个核心未解决问题,而不是常规预处理步骤。我们回顾了当前方法,强调了关键的方法学局限性,包括缺乏适当的指标和黄金标准基准,并提出了一个社区驱动的推进路径。建立共享的评估框架、可扩展的基准数据集和透明的报告标准,对于将SRT转变为生物学发现和临床转化的稳健且可重复的基础至关重要。
Spatially resolved transcriptomics (SRT) is transforming how we study tissues by measuring gene expression in cells in their spatial context. However, the field lacks robust methodological guidance on one of its most fundamental analytical steps: how to accurately segment cells and assign spatially localized transcripts to them. Major technical challenges include sparse molecular signals, transcript displacement, complex cellular morphologies, and the projection of three-dimensional tissue architecture onto two-dimensional imaging planes. These challenges make segmentation a major source of uncertainty, with errors that can propagate through downstream analyses and ultimately lead to misleading biological interpretations. Here, we argue that segmentation should be treated as a central unresolved problem in spatial omics rather than a routine preprocessing step. We review current approaches, highlight key methodological limitations, including the lack of appropriate metrics and gold-standard benchmarks, and propose a community-driven path forward. Establishing shared evaluation frameworks, scalable benchmark datasets, and transparent reporting standards will be essential for transforming SRT into a robust and reproducible foundation for biological discovery and clinical translation.